Showing posts with label gender warfare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender warfare. Show all posts

Friday, October 3, 2008

wish we could switch up the roles



Right away this song grabs me, like unexpectedly running into an old friend on the street, like I’ve known it forever. Then, Ciara spells her name into his ear... DAMN. I think we can all tell who's wearing the pants here... and then the meaning hits me and – YES! Sure enough, I grasp for a feminist moral. For liberation from the meek female role! A universal call to throw off the chains of the patriarchy… and make someone cry?

HOLD UP. What are the rules/roles anyway?

It’s a question that’s been on my mind lately, having recently received two books from an aunt: "Getting To 'I Do,' the Secret to Doing Relationships Right;" and "Dating, Mating and Manhandling: the Ornithological Guide to Men." (is she trying to make some kind of point?). After my initial indignation, I was sucked in, fascinated with the happy ending these authors guarantee if you adopt a few simple rules - in short: "play your role!"

I mean, I know there's a lot of research and writing out there about this and I don't pretend to be any kind of expert on gender roles and the history of human mating habits (this is a blog about SONGS!). But I am skeptical of anything that reduces love and happiness to a power play, or a simple combination of techniques. Aside from the blinding sexist / heteronormative (yea I said it) assumptions inherent in positions like this, I’m still open to the possibility of role specifications playing a part in relationships.

That said, I don’t think Ciara is fully taking advantage of the perks she might be afforded if she were “Like a Boy” – i.e. fast and easy urination. I mean, anyone could “have a thing on the side” right? I don’t know what world Ciara (or her lyricist) is living in, but even if you’re going to play along with all those terribly traditional rules, I don’t think lying and cheating fall neatly into one camp.

All that said, I can still somehow relate. If you’ve been hurt, you want to throw it all back in his face. And somehow this catchy song captures the struggle while making me bob my head. So many vivid details! And the chopped-and-screwed male voice is a perfect embodiment of the collective asshole. (If it were called "Like an Asshole " I would have no argument. Maybe it's supposed to be in opposition to being "Like a Man"?) Then the blending of his voice with Ciara for the refrain “Whatchu mad, can’t handle that?” really mixes things up and blends the roles. All in all it's a vengeful song, an angry turning of the tables, and yet the video ends with Ciara kissing him on the cheek, a sweet, peace-making act. I guess she just wants to teach him a lesson. And we’re not post-feminism yet!

Monday, July 14, 2008

Gender Warfare Snooze

DISCLAIMER: this is not the "real" post I have been promising, just something I need to tackle via type before this unexpected rage settles.

Two examples of utter referential overdoze-ing. Example number one, heard on the radio this morning: Driving down Lake Washington Boulevard I was enjoying the relatively high quality of Seattle's FM until this utter BS caught my attention--"Girls Don't Care" by alt-indie band Clem Snide (name taken from Burroughs's Naked Lunch, no doubt.)



Besides such tired indicators of obscurity ("Don't listen to Frank Zappa, late Coltrane, Faust or CAN... girls don't care") the song's message is depressing, trite, and... dumb. Ironically, it also proves successful as I, Girl, do not care about Clem Snide or their snide ballad by said song's finish. Or, perhaps, it's the opposite -- I care more than ever --I hate this song, and this Boy. Truly, lines like "the girls just want a sweet melody" serve as antithesis/antichrist to all theories of love, genius, etc. It makes me feel bored, sick, alone. Yeah, sometimes The Girls don't care. Sometimes The Boys don't either (hypothetical comparative ratio: FRANK ZAPPA: BONNIE RAITT??)But, if The Boys can't seem to refrain from feeling sorry for their unappreciated tastes, one would hope that The Girls could rise above and avoid such referential anthems of their own.

Unfortunately, looks like they can't. Ever since I began to contemplate Kate Perry's absurd, catchy, yet ultimately obnoxious "I Kissed a Girl" (according to a recent interview, highest play count on Madonna's ipod!!!) I have found myself repeatedly watching, showing, and gaping at her videos. Perry's other big hit -- "Ur So Gay" seems to, in some ways, serve as the She equivalent to "Girls Don't Care."



Again, so much cultural critique, of such a low caliber, all crammed into a totally elementary verse-chorus-verse structure: recipe for disaster; immediate disenchantment (mine). In this second case, there is really not much to say. Watching this video makes me feel bad. Like someone made a Zoolander-esque spoof movie about My Generation that failed to be funny, but still was a box office hit, the type that you hear strangers quoting in public spaces too often.

And...I forgot my point. Maybe it's that I like pop songs, and I like liking them, and songs like these make me sad, because I can't seem to forgive them for turning me off. They're redundant and shallow -- not even biting, because their whole critique is so over played. What is to be done? Nothing.

However, in resistance (equal parts to these enemy songs, and to my own urge to not post this post,) I'll leave on an antidotal, if not completely cultish and utopian, note.